WokeWarn
SAS Rogue Heroes poster

Woke rating

SAS Rogue Heroes

TV series · 2022– · 60 min episodes · Drama, War & Politics, Action & Adventure · Created by Steven Knight · IMDb

1.0/10

None or negligible

A brash, foul-mouthed account of how the SAS was born in the North African desert, with next to no progressive messaging: the hero's affair with an Algerian intelligence officer counts under the rubric's couple rule, and the rest is the usual soldiers' scorn for the brass.

Steven Knight's six-part series dramatises the founding of the SAS in 1941 and 1942, drawing on Ben Macintyre's history. David Stirling (Connor Swindells), a bored, hard-drinking Guards officer in Cairo, talks his way into General Auchinleck's office with a plan to raid Rommel's airfields from the desert, and recruits the volatile Ulsterman Paddy Mayne (Jack O'Connell) and the exacting Jock Lewes (Alfie Allen). In Cairo, the deception chief Dudley Clarke (Dominic West), who invented the SAS name for a phantom regiment, and Eve Mansour (Sofia Boutella), an Algerian officer in Free French intelligence, play their own games around the unit. It is loud and profane, scored with anachronistic rock and punk, and most of its running time goes to drops, desert drives and night raids.

The rubric finds very little. Stirling's affair with Eve runs through all six episodes and counts under the rule for interracial couples, though race is never mentioned. Eve, the only major female character, is a capable operator who works the high command to get Free French paratroopers into the fight. The men's contempt for GHQ, and Mayne's grudge against the landed gentry, recur as character and banter. Clarke is played as a camp, theatrical figure, and Mayne's bond with a fellow Ulsterman is treated by others as something like love, but the series comments on neither.

The rubric finds very little. Stirling's affair with Eve runs through all six episodes, until her plane is lost in a sandstorm, and counts under the rule for interracial couples, though race is never mentioned. Eve, the only major female character, is a capable operator who works the high command to get Free French paratroopers into the fight. The men's contempt for GHQ, and Mayne's grudge against the landed gentry, recur as character and banter. Clarke is played as a camp, theatrical figure, and Mayne's grief for Eoin McGonigal, killed on the first drop, is treated by others as something like love, but the series comments on neither.

What keeps the score at the bottom of the scale is that nothing is argued. No speech carries a social message, the enemy is the Axis war machine, and the series is un-PC by design, with ethnic insults and crude sex talk played as barracks humour. What little it contains is complicated: Eve is drawn as ruthless rather than idealised, the 'toff' Stirling gets his unit through his father's friendship with Auchinleck, and the establishment the men mock ends up backing them.

Score breakdown

Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.

CategoryScoreWhat we saw
Content
A Race and ethnicity 2

Race never comes up as an issue. Stirling's affair with Eve Mansour, an Algerian officer in Free French intelligence, runs through all six episodes and is counted under the rubric's on-sight rule for interracial couples. Scored 2, not 3: it is a supporting thread in a war story, not a romance-driven plot.

  • S01E020:04:17Eve tells Clarke she is Algerian, not French, and is fighting to save Africa from the Nazis (0:04:24).
  • S01E020:43:44Stirling agrees to sleep with Eve while refusing to take her Frenchmen; the affair begins.
  • S01E040:43:46Alone with Eve, Stirling confides that he is a boy playing a game while his father watches (frame 0:43:30 shows them together).
  • S01E050:47:04Eve asks to stay while Stirling comes down from a raid, and tells him he can make her his business (0:49:08).
  • S01E060:03:07Recovering under Eve's care, Stirling says he thought of making her officially his girlfriend and proposing.
  • S01E060:42:34Stirling learns that Eve's plane has gone down in a sandstorm.
  • + 1 point contains spoilers
B Gender and feminism 1

A light thread: Eve, the only major female character, is a capable operator who works the British high command to get Free French paratroopers into the fight and takes over her service in Cairo. She is drawn as ruthless rather than idealised, and nothing is argued.

  • S01E010:37:20Eve, deputy head of French military intelligence in Cairo (0:35:59), tells Stirling she shares his impatience with the conduct of the war and means to do something about it.
  • S01E020:13:34She asks Clarke to propose an operation that needs French-speaking soldiers; he calls her approach flattery, then seduction (0:14:02, 0:14:36).
  • S01E040:52:49At a meeting with Auchinleck, the posting of French paratroopers to the SAS turns out to have been her idea.
  • S01E050:48:15She says she reported her boss as a drunk and now heads French intelligence in Cairo; for France, she says, she does bad things (0:48:19).
C Sexuality and gender identity 0

No LGBTQ+ message. Dudley Clarke is played as a camp, theatrical figure, and Mayne's grief for a close friendMayne's grief for Eoin McGonigal is treated by others as something like love, but neither is spelled out or commented on (see 'zeroed'). Gay slurs appear only as barracks insults.

D Power and systems 1

Contempt for GHQ runs through the series and Mayne voices a class grudge against the landed gentry, but it is the familiar anti-brass streak of a war story, aimed at caution and red tape. It is not framed as the oppression of a group, and the top brass end up backing the SAS.

  • S01E010:24:47Stirling says the generals still think they are fighting the First World War and dither while the Nazis advance.
  • S01E010:27:10He calls GHQ layer upon layer of fossilised mediocrity.
  • S01E020:19:03Mayne says the landowning toffs never invited a yeoman farmer's son to their grouse shoots; Stirling later says those toffs now run the British Army (0:23:15).
  • S01E020:36:03Clarke tells Stirling that GHQ has no faith in his plan but would welcome a few SAS men captured or killed to make its deception real.
  • S01E040:56:04Mayne says his father was stabbed from both sides by landowning gentry like Stirling.
E Cultural and historical revision 0

A dramatisation of the SAS's real founding, drawn from Ben Macintyre's history, with the real Stirling, Mayne, Lewes, Clarke, Auchinleck and the Churchills. Eve Mansour is an invented character rather than a recast real one, and the anachronistic rock and punk soundtrack is style, not a message. No established character is recast.

F Religion portrayal 0

Islam does not feature, though much of the series is set in Cairo. Religion appears as the Lord's Prayer said over the dead (S01E01 0:18:47), Clarke's mock baptism of the SAS (S01E02 0:37:41) and Lewes reading scripture before a raid (S01E04 0:10:19).

Treatment
G Antagonist coding 0

The enemy is the German and Italian war machine, seen mostly as sentries, pilots and drivers. The obstacles at home, stuffy officers and the rival Clarke, are individuals with their own vanities, and the traitor who betrays a French patrol is a German legionnaire, not a coded type (S01E06 0:39:56). No demographic or ideological out-group is cast as the villain.

H Didacticism 0

No speeches carry a progressive message. The set pieces are about daring and war, such as the unveiling of the motto Who Dares Wins (S01E04 0:38:22); Stirling's warning against 'counterproductive stereotyping' of the French is undercut in the same breath (S01E05 0:03:09).

I Message over story 0

The story follows the unit's raids and setbacks, and none of its turns bends toward a message.

J Left-leaning politics framed as good 0

No left-leaning cause is framed as good. Anti-fascism is the Allied war aim of 1942, not a partisan stance, and a recruit's taste for killing fascists in Spain (S01E02 0:48:32) is played as a quirk. Churchill is drawn as the SAS's champion (S01E06 0:06:19).

How the number is reached

  1. Categories A to J add up to 4 of 30, which gives 1.5 (4 ÷ 30 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
  2. Counterweight −0.5: the series complicates what little it contains. Eve is drawn as ruthless, offering sex as part of a deal (S01E02 0:42:51) and reporting her own boss (S01E05 0:48:15); the anti-brass grudge is undercut because Stirling, a 'toff' himself, wins his unit through his father's friendship with Auchinleck (S01E02 0:28:22, 0:31:44) and Churchill then gives him a free hand (S01E06 0:07:18); and Stirling's call to avoid stereotyping the French is mocked in the same breath (S01E05 0:03:16).
  3. Final rating 1.0, none or negligible.

Considered, scored 0

  • Dudley Clarke played as a camp, theatrical figure: he tells Eve he wishes he were French (S01E02 0:04:14), she hints that seduction may not work on him (0:14:36), and he later says he has found someone, unnamed (S01E06 0:41:19). Nothing is made of it.
  • Mayne's bond with a fellow Ulsterman, which Jordan and Stirling treat as something like love (S01E05 0:41:37, 0:53:41)Mayne's grief for Eoin McGonigal (S01E03 0:16:15, S01E04 0:45:39), which Jordan and Stirling treat as love and 'undeclared grief' (S01E05 0:41:37, 0:53:41), left unstated.
  • Halevy, a Jewish Free French soldier whose family was taken to the camps (S01E05 0:08:19), and Stirling's remark about what the Nazis are doing to children in Berlin (S01E01 0:25:11): history, not commentary.
  • Anti-fascism as the war aim: stopping fascism's advance across Africa is now down to the SAS (S01E02 0:56:15).
  • A few Black soldiers among men with raised hands during a night raid (S01E06 frame 0:31:30), shown without comment.
  • Casual sex and crude sexual talk, including Clarke's 'fucking is fine, feeling is not' (S01E03 0:34:43) and Lewes's memory of a night in a car with the woman he hopes to marry (S01E04 0:20:16): character and period colour, not sexual-freedom advocacy.

Evidence and confidence

Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles (the embedded English track) and 113 frames sampled every three minutes. All 6 of the owner's 6 episodes, the whole of season 1, were reviewed. Some short German, Italian and French exchanges at checkpoints and with the Free French are shown as burnt-in subtitles that are not in the subtitle track (for example S01E05 frames 0:22:30 and 0:37:30, S01E04 0:51:36 to 0:51:53); they are brief, and their gist is clear from the scenes around them.

Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.

Noted, not scored: The series is un-PC by design: ethnic insults about the Irish, Scots and French (S01E02 0:16:47, S01E04 0:40:09, S01E05 0:03:16), gay slurs as barracks insults (S01E02 0:16:25, S01E06 0:13:39) and a recruit taken on for having slept with twelve women (S01E02 0:50:12) are played as humour and never corrected. Martial virtue, patriotism and faith are treated with respect: the Lord's Prayer over the dead (S01E01 0:18:47), Lewes's reading of the commandment as 'thou shalt not kill except in a very good cause' against Hitler (S01E04 0:10:19), and Churchill as the unit's champion (S01E06 0:06:19).

Episodes reviewed: S01E01, S01E02, S01E03, S01E04, S01E05, S01E06.

Rubric version 1. Reviewed 18 November 2026.