
Woke rating
Voicemails for Isabelle
None or negligible
A raunchy romantic comedy about grief whose few progressive touches, a supporting interracial couple, one public callout of a dating double standard and a Michelle Obama joke, stay incidental to the love story.
Jill, a Texan prep cook slicing kumquats in a celebrity chef's San Francisco kitchen, loses her younger sister Isabelle to cystic fibrosis and keeps calling her number to leave long, confessional voicemails. The number has been passed on to the new work phone of Wes, a commitment-shy commercial real-estate man from Texas, who listens, falls for her from afar and contrives to meet her. Around the romance run Jill's fight to be promoted to baker and Wes's duties as best man at his closest friends' wedding.
The rubric finds little here. Wes's friends Andy and Breeda, whose wedding is a set piece, are an interracial couple, which the rubric counts on sight, and Jill has one date with a Black British dating podcaster. The most pointed moment comes when, ghosted by that podcaster, she stands up at his live taping and asks why accountability is only expected of women. Otherwise the politics amount to a joke about Michelle Obama and a one-night stand who cannot promise her that everything will be fine because of climate change and democracy. The last act turns on what happens when Jill learns where her voicemails have been going.
The rubric finds little here. Wes's friends Andy and Breeda, whose wedding is a set piece, are an interracial couple, which the rubric counts on sight, and Jill has one date with a Black British dating podcaster. The most pointed moment comes when, ghosted by that podcaster, she stands up at his live taping and asks why accountability is only expected of women. Otherwise the politics amount to a joke about Michelle Obama and a one-night stand who cannot promise her that everything will be fine because of climate change and democracy. When Jill learns at the wedding that Wes has heard every voicemail, she tells him she does not need a man, she needs her sister. She loses the baker job to a rival who sabotaged her, quits and opens a food truck with her parents' gift of Isabelle's college fund, while Wes gives up his most prized collectible to have her lost voicemails from Isabelle recovered. They reunite on New Year's Eve, and he turns her words round: she may not need a man, but he needs her.
What keeps the score this low is that the humour cuts every way. Jill's rival in the kitchen calls the idea of baking as women's work sexist to impress her, then rates her a 6.5; Wes's ex dumps him in therapy-speak; and Jill is accused of using a man and dropping him. The film's foils are individuals with their own motives, the male lead is sympathetic, and the story stays a straightforward romanceit ends as a straightforward romance, with Wes asking the dead sister's blessing to move in with Jill.
Score breakdown
Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Race and ethnicity | 2 | Race is never discussed, but the rubric counts an interracial couple on sight. Wes's closest friends Andy and Breeda, an Asian man and a white woman, are a recurring supporting couple whose wedding is a set piece, and Jill has a single date with Tyler, a Black British podcaster. Scored 2 for the supporting couple, with no message attached.
|
| B Gender and feminism | 1 | One scene and a few lines raise a gender double standard in dating, each tied to Jill's own grievances. Women's place is not a theme of the film.
|
| C Sexuality and gender identity | 0 | No LGBTQ characters or themes. The sex talk is frank and frequent, including a one-night stand and jokes about a 'gay awakening' and selling feet pictures, but it is comedy, not advocacy, and Jill spends much of the film swearing off men. |
| D Power and systems | 0 | No institution is framed as oppressing a group. The bullying celebrity chef is mocked as a fraud, a Wisconsin native faking a French accent (1:24:27), and a colleague's text-hacking for Wes's real-estate deals (0:23:55) is a matter of personal ethics. |
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | A contemporary romantic comedy. No established characters, source material or history are recast to carry a message. |
| F Religion portrayal | 0 | Islam does not appear. Religion is limited to Jill's eulogy saying Isabelle believed in angels and fate (0:14:22). |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | The foils are men (a rival prep cook, a ghosting podcaster, a bullying chef), but each has his own motive: the rival's revenge after Jill drops him, the podcaster's vanity, the chef's ego. The male lead is sympathetic, Jill's father is loving, and Wes's ex is as hard on him as any man is on Jill. |
| H Didacticism | 0 | No one lectures. Jill's outburst at the podcast taping is a personal revenge that ends with her fleeing in embarrassment (0:43:04), counted under B, and her line about not needing a man comes in a row about griefcomes in the row over the voicemails and is about her sister. |
| I Message over story | 0 | The story is a grief-and-romance comedy, and its turns serve the love story rather than a message. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 1 | Two passing jokes touch on politics: the heroine calls Michelle Obama 'our queen', and a one-night stand frets about climate change and democracy, with the joke on him. Nothing is argued, and no conservative view is put down.
|
How the number is reached
- Categories A to J add up to 4 of 30, which gives 1.5 (4 ÷ 30 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
- Counterweight −0.5: The film mocks its own talking points: Jill's rival calls the idea of baking as women's work sexist to impress her (0:20:03), then rates her a 6.5 (0:20:37); Wes's ex dumps him in therapy-speak about holding space and secure attachment (0:20:09); Jill is accused of using the rival and kicking him to the curb (0:23:10); and she frames her podcast callout as going lower, not high (0:40:12).
- Final rating 1.0, none or negligible.
Considered, scored 0
- A mixed supporting cast, including a Black executive at Wes's firm (frame 0:39:30), shown without comment.
- The sisters calling each other 'brother' and 'my lad' (0:11:25, 1:43:00), a family in-joke, not a gender theme.
- Jill joking that she is on a 'dick cleanse' awaiting her 'gay awakening' (0:25:02), Wes's crude joke about breakfast tacos (0:18:40) and a Brokeback Mountain quote (0:38:03).
- A one-night stand (0:21:30) and frequent raunchy talk, including a no-judgment joke about selling feet pictures (0:48:48), played as comedy.
- A date dismissing pink eye as fake news made up by Big Pharma (0:05:33), a joke at his expense.
- The celebrity chef's abuse of his cooks as 'prep piggies' (1:19:08) and a jab at 'prep girls' (0:55:00); he bullies everyone, and sexism is never the charge.
- A colleague hacking texts for Wes's real-estate deals (0:23:55), personal ethics rather than a critique of business.
Evidence and confidence
Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles from the embedded track, including song lyrics and the chef's French, and 118 frames sampled once a minute. The Dolby Vision source makes the frames dark, but faces and settings are readable; the couples were checked on enlarged frames.
Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.
Rubric version 1. Reviewed 18 November 2026.