WokeWarn
The Red Virgin poster

Woke rating

The Red Virgin

2024 · 114 min · Drama, History, Thriller · Directed by Paula Ortiz · IMDb

2.5/10

Mild

A Spanish true-story drama about a teenage sex reformer of the 1930s that makes women's emancipation its subject, but turns a hard eye on the mother who embodies those ideas most fiercely and kills for them.

Based on real events, the film tells the story of Aurora Rodríguez Carballeira, who set out to conceive and raise a daughter as 'the woman of the future', and of that daughter, Hildegart, who at 17 is Spain's youngest lawyer and a famous writer on sexual reform in the first years of the Second Republic. Most of it is a chamber drama about a mother who plans every minute of her child's life, and a daughter who starts to want a life of her own after she meets a young socialist, Abel.

Women's emancipation is the film's subject. An editor refuses to believe a 16-year-old girl wrote her article, Hildegart's first speech scolds the Socialist Party for ignoring women and the rapes in the news, the party office has no women's toilet, and a publisher cannot make a cheque out to a woman. Her causes, sex education, birth control and limited legal abortion, are presented as forward-looking, and a closing card regrets that her work was forgotten after the Civil War. The last act turns the theme back on the household in ways that keep the score in check.

Women's emancipation is the film's subject. An editor refuses to believe a 16-year-old girl wrote her article, Hildegart's first speech scolds the Socialist Party for ignoring women and the rapes in the news, the party office has no women's toilet, and a publisher cannot make a cheque out to a woman. Her causes, sex education, birth control and limited legal abortion, are presented as forward-looking, and a closing card regrets that her work was forgotten after the Civil War. The last act turns the theme on its own champion: Aurora pays the maid's husband, the real rapist, to frame Abel, Hildegart tells her mother she wants to own her the way men own women, and Aurora shoots her in her bed and tells the men judging her that they never understood her.

What keeps the score down is that the film does not flatter its feminist side. The fiercest feminist in it is a controlling eugenicist who destroys her own daughter, Hildegart insists the fight is alongside men rather than against them, the Socialist Party is shown ignoring women and covering for its own, and the working-class maid Macarena tells Hildegart her speeches do not fit real life. The speeches are given at rallies, where speeches belong, and several of the men around Hildegart are decent.

Score breakdown

Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.

CategoryScoreWhat we saw
Content
A Race and ethnicity 0

Race never comes up. The cast is Spanish, and no interracial couple is shown.

B Gender and feminism 3

The dominant theme. The film opens with Aurora's plan to make the first free woman, and Hildegart's career is a running fight against men who doubt, ignore or exclude women, from editors and party comrades to the law. Scored 3 despite the film's own doubts about Aurora, which are counted in the counterweight.

  • 0:02:11Aurora's narration: reading about eugenics and women's rights taught her that women must shape humanity's future, so she conceived a child that would be hers alone (0:02:35).
  • 0:08:18The editor says no 16-year-old woman could write the article; Aurora asks if he would doubt it were she a man (0:09:43).
  • 0:25:11In her first speech Hildegart reads out a newspaper report of a woman raped in Chamberí and lists the women raped, beaten and dying in childbirth; she counts 70 men and 2 women in the room (0:26:08).
  • 0:31:55There is no women's toilet at the party office; Abel suggests she write about it as a metaphor (0:33:04).
  • 0:37:30The publisher needs a man's name to make out her royalty cheque.
  • 0:46:17When party men shrug off the anarchist gang's rapes, they are told they would not look away if they were the victims.
  • 1:37:00Hildegart tells Aurora she wants to own her just as men own women, and that nobody owns them.
  • 1:44:05Aurora tells the men judging her that 'you men' never saw she was a planet with her own light.
  • + 2 points contain spoilers
C Sexuality and gender identity 2

Sexual reform is Hildegart's public cause and the subject of her books, and the film presents it as enlightened. Scored 2, not 3: the ideas are mostly named rather than argued, and there are no LGBTQ characters or storylines.

  • 0:09:22Hildegart recites the programme of Havelock Ellis's sexual-reform league: equal rights, marriage freed from the Church, birth control for the poor, protection for unmarried mothers and understanding of intersex variants (0:09:35).
  • 0:12:39Macarena says everyone wants to know about the young woman lawyer who writes about sex.
  • 0:18:20An anatomy lesson at home on the clitoris and female arousal.
  • 0:52:10Hildegart's new essay says the sexual organs are no more private than the rest of the body; book covers on sex education and birth control fill the frame (0:52:30).
D Power and systems 1

Institutions come off badly mainly as obstacles for women, scored under B. Beyond that the Socialist Party is attacked from the left for nepotism and broken promises, as a political critique rather than oppression of a group.

  • 0:57:52A headline attacks the ambition of the 'social-nepotists'.
  • 1:05:30On Hildegart and Abel's date, the socialists are mocked for winning on one programme and carrying out another.
  • 1:21:21Abel agrees with Hildegart that the party has betrayed the labour movement and cares only about elections.
E Cultural and historical revision 0

A dramatisation of the life of Hildegart Rodríguez, flagged as based on real events (0:00:32), with real figures such as Julián Besteiro and Havelock Ellis named. Nothing in the material shows characters recast or history altered to carry a message.

F Religion portrayal 0

Islam does not feature. Religion appears only as a crowd's anti-Catholic shout and the hate graffiti on the house.

Treatment
G Antagonist coding 0

The main antagonist is Aurora herself, a feminist and eugenicist with a full personal motive. The men who doubt or ignore Hildegart are minor and some come round, the real rapist is an anarchist, and the vandals who paint 'witches' and 'whores' on the house are never seen.

H Didacticism 2

Hildegart's speeches state the message directly, and several exchanges spell it out. All are in character: she is a public speaker, and the lines come at rallies, in her essays and in a family row.

  • 0:24:25Speech to the Socialist Party: it boasts of equality but ignores half the country, women; if they want a fairer Spain they should start with that room (0:26:53).
  • 0:48:09Second speech: women will fight not against men but alongside them; the hall sings the Internationale (0:48:26).
  • 1:36:27Hildegart tells her mother men are not their enemies, that she hates women for being able to feel, and that there is no revolution without love.
  • 1:48:22Closing card: Hildegart wrote 16 books and over 150 articles, and her work and her peers' was forgotten after the Civil War.
  • + 1 point contains spoilers
I Message over story 0

The story leads. It follows the real case, and its turns grow out of Aurora's need for control and Hildegart's wish for a life of her own. A few short scenes, such as the missing women's toilet, exist mainly to make a point, but they do not bend the plot.

J Left-leaning politics framed as good 2

Hildegart's left-wing causes, from birth control and limited legal abortion to socialist revolution, are framed as the hopeful side of history, and the closing card blames the Civil War for burying them. Scored 2, not 3: the socialist and anarchist movements themselves are shown as hypocritical.

  • 0:53:22The socialist election win is greeted with cheers and a 'victory of the people' headline.
  • 0:53:45Talk of a regulated abortion system leads to Hildegart's draft making abortion non-punishable after rape, when the mother's life is at risk or when she cannot care for the child, which Aurora reads aloud (0:54:12).
  • 1:34:58Hildegart tells her mother she is starting to sound like a fascist.
  • + 1 point contains spoilers

How the number is reached

  1. Categories A to J add up to 10 of 30, which gives 3.5 (10 ÷ 30 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
  2. Counterweight −1.0: the film complicates its own message throughout: its fiercest feminist is a controlling eugenicist who treats her daughter as a project (0:55:25, 0:56:22); Hildegart says women fight alongside men, not against them (0:48:09); party men excuse rapes to keep the left united (0:46:06); the working-class Macarena tells Hildegart her speeches do not match life (1:32:35); and Guzmán, Abel and Pepe are decent men with their own motives.Aurora, the film's fiercest feminist, is a controlling eugenicist who frames an innocent man (1:31:57) and kills her daughter as a failed project (1:44:45), and Hildegart calls her the enemy of her own ideas (1:35:31); Hildegart says women fight alongside men, not against them (0:48:09, 1:36:27); party men excuse rapes to keep the left united (0:46:06), and the real rapist is an anarchist; Macarena tells Hildegart her speeches do not match life (1:32:35); and Guzmán, Abel and Pepe are decent men with their own motives.
  3. Final rating 2.5, mild.

Considered, scored 0

  • A Spanish cast; race does not come up, and the couple at the centre (Hildegart and Abel) is not interracial.
  • Crowds at the proclamation of the Republic, with republican, monarchist and anti-Catholic shouts (0:10:24 to 0:11:36): period colour.
  • The subplot about Pepe, the nephew Aurora raised as a piano prodigy until his mother took him back (0:28:57, 1:09:56): family history with no message.
  • The cabaret song about lovers from different classes on Hildegart and Abel's first date (1:05:35): romance, not argument.
  • Aurora calling Havelock Ellis and H. G. Wells English imperialists (0:38:30): character, not comment.

Evidence and confidence

Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles from the embedded track (flagged as forced, but it holds the complete dialogue and translates the on-screen headlines, graffiti and songs), and 115 frames sampled once a minute, the last seven of them end credits. The HDR frames are washed out but readable. A few wordless stretches, such as the cabaret scene (1:02:39 to 1:04:38) and a passage late in the film (1:38:35 to 1:43:01), are covered only by the frames.

Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.

Noted, not scored: Some threads cut against progressive certainty: the eugenic plan to perfect humanity is shown as dehumanising, the left is shown covering for crimes against women by its own allies (0:45:54, 0:46:06), and the film sides with love over ideology, against Aurora's claim that love is a weakness (0:56:22); Hildegart answers that there is no revolution without love (1:36:40).

Rubric version 1. Reviewed 18 November 2026.