
Woke rating
Poor Things
Moderate
A Victorian fantasy whose heroine's sexual and intellectual liberation from the men who try to own her is its whole point, told as an absurdist comedy that also pokes fun at her naive idealism.
Yorgos Lanthimos's adaptation of Alasdair Gray's 1992 novel follows Bella Baxter (Emma Stone), a young woman brought back to life by the scarred surgeon Godwin Baxter (Willem Dafoe) with the brain of the infant she was carrying. She begins with a child's mind and grows up fast. Godwin keeps her inside his London house and engages her to his student Max McCandles (Ramy Youssef), but she runs off with the lawyer Duncan Wedderburn (Mark Ruffalo) on a journey through Lisbon, a cruise ship, Alexandria and Paris. The world is stylised, partly in black and white, and the sex is frequent and explicit.
The messaging is the story. Each man around Bella tries to contain her: Godwin keeps her indoors as an experiment, the engagement contract confines her to the house, and Duncan, who promises to free her, soon wants to control what she says and where she goes. Bella treats sex as a discovery and polite society as the enemy. On the ship she wonders why Emerson gives no advice to women, and in Alexandria the sight of dead children in a slum turns her toward improving the world. In Paris she takes up work that puts her ideas about sex and independence to the test, alongside a socialist friend, and the last act brings in a man who stands for everything she has been escaping.
The messaging is the story. Each man around Bella tries to contain her: Godwin keeps her indoors as an experiment, the engagement contract confines her to the house, and Duncan, who promises to free her, soon wants to control what she says and where she goes. Bella treats sex as a discovery and polite society as the enemy. On the ship she wonders why Emerson gives no advice to women, and in Alexandria the sight of dead children in a slum turns her toward improving the world. In Paris she works in a brothel, argues that the women should choose their clients, and tells Duncan they are their own means of production on the way to a socialist meeting. Back in London she learns her origin, and Victoria's husband, General Blessington, claims her, threatens to shoot her if she leaves and plans to have her clitoris cut off so she will settle into bearing children. Max, by contrast, tells her it is her body to give freely.
What keeps it in the moderate band is that the comedy cuts more than one way. Bella's charity is naive (she hands Duncan's winnings to ship's crewmen who promise to pass them on) and she admits she does not think things through; the women around her are not idealisedthe brothel's madam is a woman who runs it on rules she calls sick but good business; the cynic Harry gets a full hearing; and Godwin and Max, who also hold her back at first, are drawn with warmth. Race hardly figures, the targets are Victorian conventions rather than present-day parties, and the novel already carries the same themes. Against that, the gender and sexual-freedom message is central and repeated, and the male antagonists are drawn as types of possessiveness, which puts it at the top of the band.
Score breakdown
Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Race and ethnicity | 1 | Race is never a theme. The rubric's on-sight rule picks up one brief pairing: Bella and Toinette, a Black woman she meets in Paris, are shown in bed together. Harry, a Black passenger, is a friend rather than a romance, and Max's casting is not counted (see zeroed).
|
| B Gender and feminism | 3 | The film's spine is Bella's escape from men who confine, correct or claim her, with repeated lines about men's weakness, women's place and male ownership, ending with a husband who wants her mutilated and pregnant and her decision to become a doctor.
|
| C Sexuality and gender identity | 3 | Sexual freedom is the dominant message: Bella's discovery of pleasure is played as liberation, shame and possessiveness as the obstacles, and her later experience is framed as self-discoveryand her sex work is framed as freedom and self-discovery. It ends with a fiancé who accepts her past and a husband who plans to excise her clitoris.
|
| D Power and systems | 2 | Poverty and class recur and drive the plot: Bella's shock in Alexandria leads her to give money away, which strands her in Pariswhich strands her in Paris and leads to the brothel, where she meets socialists and the economics of sex work. Godwin also knocks how society treats suicides, but the critique is sketched rather than argued at length.
|
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | An adaptation of Alasdair Gray's 1992 novel, whose Bella also ends with radical views on societybecomes a doctor with radical views on society, so the themes come from the source. The story moves from Glasgow to a stylised London; Max's casting is not counted as a recast (see zeroed). |
| F Religion portrayal | 0 | Islam is not portrayed; Alexandria appears only as a hotel and a slum seen from above. Religion figures as Godwin's nickname, God, and in his remark about the Christian nation's view of suicide (0:22:48). |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 2 | The men who try to own Bella are drawn as types of male possessiveness: Duncan's libertine charm turns to rage and name-calling once she acts as freely as he does, and the last act's antagonist is a caricature, and the general, a wealthy soldier who calls his life the taking of territory, wants her circumcised and pregnant, with no motive beyond possession. Scored 2, not 3: Godwin and Max, who also confine her at first, are loving and forgiven, and Duncan's jealousy is personal.
|
| H Didacticism | 2 | Many lines state the themes outright, from Bella's views on improving society to the madam's creed and Max's acceptance, but they are short, in character and mostly played for comedy rather than delivered as lectures.
|
| I Message over story | 2 | The picaresque is built as a liberation allegory: each man who tries to keep Bella is left behind and diminished, and the last act brings in a figure who exists to voice and enact controla husband who exists to voice and enact patriarchal control. Scored 2, not 3: the fantasy premise motivates the structure, and the comedy keeps Bella herself fallible.
|
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 2 | Socialism is welcomed and polite society, sexual convention and possessive marriage are cast as the enemy. Scored 2, not 3: the overt politics is a sketch carried by a few lines, the targets are Victorian conventions rather than a present-day camp, and the film's feminism is scored under B.
|
How the number is reached
- Categories A to J add up to 17 of 30, which gives 5.5 (17 ÷ 30 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
- Counterweight −0.5: the film mocks its heroine's idealism and does not idealise the women around her: Bella's charity is naive and she admits she does not think things through (1:25:04), she finds cruelty bubbling up in herself (1:15:16), Harry's cynicism gets a full hearing (1:23:14), and the men who first confine her, Godwin and Max, are drawn with warmth.Bella hands Duncan's winnings to crewmen who promise to pass them to the poor (1:19:28, 1:22:08) and admits she does not think things through (1:25:04); she finds cruelty bubbling up in herself (1:15:16) and learns that her former self was unkind (2:04:22); the madam, a woman, exploits the workers for good business and bites Bella's ear (1:35:21, 1:36:06); Harry's cynicism, which lumps socialism with religion and capitalism, gets a full hearing (1:23:14); and Godwin and Max are forgiven and loved (1:55:39, 1:57:40).
- Final rating 5.0, moderate.
Considered, scored 0
- Harry, a Black passenger on the cruise and Bella's intellectual sparring partner (frames 1:06:30, 1:16:30), shown without comment on race.
- Max McCandles played by Ramy Youssef, an actor of Egyptian descent (frame 2:12:30), in a role the novel writes as a Scottish medical student. The film gives Max no ethnic marker and the casting is not visibly a change of race, so neither his engagement to Bella nor the casting is counted under A or E.
- Bella's night with Toinette (frame 1:47:30) as a same-sex encounter, shown without comment; it counts only under A's on-sight rule, while C is scored for the sexual-freedom message as a whole.
- The explicit sex and nudity as such; the score counts how the film frames sex, not how much it shows.
- Max's crude remark on first seeing Bella (0:07:29), a line in character.
- Godwin's accounts of his father's experiments on him (0:17:42, 0:27:56, 1:00:07), backstory with no social message.
Evidence and confidence
Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles from the embedded track, and 142 frames sampled once a minute. The track starts at 0:04:37, so the opening minutes rest on the frames alone, and a few French words in the Paris scenes are left as spoken (1:33:35).
Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.
Rubric version 1. Reviewed 18 November 2026.