
Woke rating
Memory
None or negligible
A quiet New York drama about a recovering alcoholic with a history of childhood abuse and a man with dementia, with almost no progressive messaging: the abuse is one family's buried history, not a point about men.
Michel Franco's drama follows Sylvia (Jessica Chastain), a social worker 13 years sober who lives with her teenage daughter Anna, works at an adult daycare centre and goes to AA meetings. After a high-school reunion a stranger, Saul (Peter Sarsgaard), follows her home and spends the night outside her building. He turns out to have dementia, his family asks Sylvia to keep him company during the day, and the two lonely people grow close.
What the rubric could count is Sylvia's past. She was sexually abused as a girl, and much of the drama turns on who in her family knew and who believed her. It is told as one woman's history, with no talk about men or women in general, and the man at the centre of the story is gentle and vulnerable. The rest is about memory, sobriety and how far Saul's family may run his life.
What the rubric could count is Sylvia's past. In a park she accuses Saul of having abused her at school with an older boy (0:30:15), then finds out he joined the school after she left and apologises (0:42:30). The abuse by the older boy was real, and her mother moved her to another school rather than believe her (0:43:00). At a family gathering Sylvia says her father abused her from the age of eight and her mother protected him; the mother calls her a liar, and her sister Olivia confirms what she saw as a child (1:21:38, 1:23:12). Alongside this runs Saul's struggle with his brother Isaac, who blocks his cards and keeps him indoors for his own good (1:13:47, 1:36:35), until Anna helps him back to Sylvia (1:38:15).
The score stays near zero because nothing is preached. The abuse is drawn as a family's buried secret rather than a point about men, and the film complicates its heroine's own accountSylvia's first accusation lands on the wrong man, the parent who looked away is her mother, and Saul, the man she suspected, is the gentlest character in the film. The AA group and the daycare residents, of varied backgrounds, are simply part of Sylvia's world.
Score breakdown
Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Race and ethnicity | 0 | Race never comes up. Sylvia's AA group and the daycare centre include people of varied backgrounds (frames 0:02:30, 0:05:30), shown without comment, and no interracial couple appears in the dialogue or the sampled frames. |
| B Gender and feminism | 1 | Sylvia's sexual abuse as a girl and her family's responseher mother's denial drive the drama: an older boy at school and her father abused her, and her mother refused to believe her. Scored 1, not 2: it is told as one woman's history rather than argued as a point about men or patriarchy, and the film complicates her account; her first accusation is aimed at the wrong man, the one who looked away is her mother, and Saul is gentle throughout.
|
| C Sexuality and gender identity | 0 | No LGBTQ characters or themes. The one romance is Sylvia and Saul's, with brief intimate scenes (frames 1:17:30, 1:20:30). |
| D Power and systems | 0 | No institution is criticised. Isaac's control over Saul's life (1:19:30) is a family's protectiveness toward a man with dementia, not a system oppressing a group, and the daycare centre where Sylvia works is shown as a caring place (0:04:21). |
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | An original story. No established characters or history are recast. |
| F Religion portrayal | 0 | Religion plays no part beyond the Serenity Prayer at an AA meeting (1:33:47). |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | The people who wronged Sylvia are individuals, an older schoolboy and members of her own familyan older schoolboy, her father and the mother who looked away, not stand-ins for a group. Isaac is overbearing but acts out of worry for his brother (1:19:30). |
| H Didacticism | 0 | No speeches carry a social message. The AA shares (0:01:03, 0:38:40) are about sobriety, and Sylvia's accusations are part of a family quarrelin the family showdown (1:21:38) are a confrontation, not lectures. |
| I Message over story | 0 | A slow, character-led drama; nothing in it bends toward a message. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 0 | No political positions appear. |
How the number is reached
- Categories A to J add up to 1 of 30, which gives 0.5 (1 ÷ 30 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
- Counterweight −0.5: The film complicates its one theme rather than pressing it: it does not treat its heroine's every claim as beyond question, and the man at the centre of the story is gentle and vulnerableSylvia's accusation against Saul proves mistaken and she apologises (0:30:15, 0:42:30); the parent who refused to believe her is her mother, and her sister kept silent for years (1:24:00, 1:28:13); and Saul, the man she suspected, is the gentlest character in the film.
- Final rating 0.0, none or negligible.
Considered, scored 0
- Sylvia's AA group and the adult daycare residents, of varied backgrounds, shown without comment (frames 0:02:30, 0:05:30).
- The romance between Sylvia and Saul, with brief intimate scenes (frames 1:17:30, 1:20:30), which Isaac tries to stop when his daughter tells him what she saw (1:09:56): a story about a man with dementia and his say over his own life, not a message about sexuality.
- Isaac's control over Saul's life (1:19:30), blocking his cards and keeping him indoors (1:13:47, 1:36:35), a family conflict about care rather than a critique of institutions.
- Sylvia's mother worrying about the neighbourhood and offering money for a better flat (0:41:02, 0:41:12), family friction rather than commentary on class.
- Sylvia's strict rules for Anna about parties and drinking (0:46:29), a recovering alcoholic's caution.
Evidence and confidence
Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles from the embedded track, and 103 frames sampled once a minute; the last four are end credits. Several quiet scenes play with little or no dialogue (for example 0:12:18 to 0:15:11 and 1:15:32 to 1:18:24), which the frames cover.
Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.
Rubric version 1. Reviewed 18 November 2026.