
Woke rating
Jimmy Carr: Natural Born Killer
Mild
Jimmy Carr's stand-up hour jokes about trans people, religion, rape and cancel culture with nothing held back, but a sincere point about how society treats rape and a long, crude consent lesson for a 19-year-old give it a mild progressive streak.
Jimmy Carr's 2024 stand-up special opens by promising to prove that you can still joke about anything. A fast run of one-liners covers porn, dementia, Norfolk, veganism, guns, abortion, anti-vaxxers, trans people, rape and cancel culture. The middle turns to religion, fatherhood and a true story about his premature son, and the last third is crowd work: an engaged couple, a man who has not proposed after ten years, and a closing mock sex-education lesson for Jacob, a 19-year-old in the audience with his dad.
The progressive notes come in a few places. After a string of rape jokes, Carr argues in earnest that society does not take rape seriously enough and that 'date rape' should just be called rape (0:20:48). A long routine on fatherhood says mothers do all the work and fathers at best babysit (0:32:53). The closing lesson tells Jacob that young men lack the sex education girls get from women, then spells out one consent per act, talking to the girl, and words and body language that must match (0:47:01 to 0:58:48). He says he will call trans people whatever they want to be called, and calls the classification of homosexuality as a mental illness until 1979 stupid. One-liners take shots at AR-15 owners, the US Supreme Court on abortion and anti-vaxxers.
What keeps the score low is that nearly every sincere point is followed at once by a joke that runs the other way, and much of the hour argues against progressive positions. The respectful line on pronouns comes after a list of pronouns ending in 'oh gross'. 'Trans women are women' is the set-up for a misogyny joke, and the parenting routine ends by calling stay-at-home dads pussies. Carr defends offensive jokes against cancel culture, mocks 'woke nonsense' and explains that he jokes about Jesus but not Muhammad because he is not an idiot. The rubric measures progressive messaging only, so that material is noted rather than scored.
Score breakdown
Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Race and ethnicity | 0 | Race and ethnicity come up only as joke material (Hong Kong's Chinatown, gypsies, an Australian audience member), with no message. |
| B Gender and feminism | 2 | Gender recurs across the hour: a sincere point that rape is not taken seriously because its victims are mostly women, a fatherhood routine built on mothers doing all the work, and a consent lesson framed around young men being left uneducated. All of it is wrapped in jokes, several of them misogynist.
|
| C Sexuality and gender identity | 1 | Two brief sympathetic lines, each set among jokes that cut the other way: a promise to respect trans people's pronouns, and a remark that classifying homosexuality as a mental illness until 1979 was stupid.
|
| D Power and systems | 1 | Two one-liners about American institutions: police shooting the unarmed, and the Supreme Court restricting abortion.
|
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | Original stand-up material; no established characters or history are recast. |
| F Religion portrayal | 0 | Islam is not portrayed. Carr skips his 'Islamic bit', saying he is not stupid enough to joke about Muhammad, which is a joke about fear of violence, the opposite of a corrective message. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | There are no antagonists, only targets, and they cut every way: anti-vaxxers, people trying to cancel him, Christians, dads, young men and women. |
| H Didacticism | 2 | Two passages state a message directly: the short argument about how society talks about rape, and the closing consent lesson, which lays out rules for Jacob between the jokes. Both are delivered as comedy, but the rules are meant sincerely.
|
| I Message over story | 0 | The hour follows a stand-up's usual run of topics and crowd work; the consent lesson is the closing bit and stays a comedy routine. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 1 | Quick one-liners side with gun control, abortion rights and vaccination, each played for a laugh.
|
How the number is reached
- Categories A to J add up to 7 of 30, which gives 2.5 (7 ÷ 30 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
- Counterweight −0.5: Carr undercuts several of his own progressive moments within seconds: rape statistics lead into 'I like those odds' (0:20:24); the respectful line on pronouns follows a pronoun list ending 'it, oh gross, what, is, that' (0:16:38); 'trans women are women' is the set-up for an 'old-fashioned misogyny' punchline (0:18:39); the fatherhood routine calls stay-at-home dads pussies (0:33:36); and the consent lesson mocks the phrase 'enthusiastic consent' (0:51:15) and ends in jokes about ovulation and 'don't stick your dick in crazy' (0:52:21, 0:53:47). The consent message itself is not undercut, so the deduction stays at 0.5.
- Final rating 2.0, mild.
Considered, scored 0
- Ethnic one-liners about Hong Kong's Chinatown (0:00:58), gypsies ('they've moved on', 0:23:20) and Australian tattoos (0:43:01), told for laughs.
- Gay and trans one-liners: a transgender half-brother (0:01:07), 'one man in ten is gay' (0:19:38) and a gender reveal held at 21 (0:30:09); joke material, no message.
- A 'climate change' line that is a joke about his niece (0:09:44), and a Greta Thunberg joke about reusing condoms (0:48:38).
- Four minutes of jokes about the Virgin Mary, Jesus and Adam and Eve (0:25:37 to 0:28:33), closing with Carr saying he is an atheist and that it is 'all made up'; irreverent material rather than a political message.
- Jokes about learning disability, from a 'special' collecting trolleys (0:05:08) to a charity worker's 'kind regards' typo (0:22:42).
- The frames show Carr alone on stage throughout, with occasional cutaways to laughing audience members (0:09:30, 0:41:30, 0:47:30, 0:56:30); no couples are shown on stage.
Evidence and confidence
Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles from the file's embedded track, covering the whole set from the opening (0:00:15) to the sign-off (0:59:10), plus 60 frames sampled once a minute. Some audience replies during crowd work are only partly captured.
Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.
Noted, not scored: The special's frame is a challenge to offence culture: people say you can't joke about anything these days, 'Watch me now' (0:00:17). Cancel culture is a recurring target: he is going down swinging (0:22:08), plans a fake apology (0:23:28), and tells people trying to cancel him 'I'm sorry you feel that way' and 'good luck with that' (0:25:16). 'This woke nonsense, it's gone too far' leads into a 'male queen' joke (0:23:09). He will not joke about Muhammad because he is 'not a fucking idiot', and tells Christians who find that unfair that they should think about blowing something up; no one is scared of Christians (0:28:52 to 0:29:28). Trans jokes: the pronoun list ending 'oh gross' (0:16:38), and a towel-turban test to decide who uses the women's changing room (0:18:09). Jokes about postnatal depression and seeing your wife naked (0:32:21), women who are ovulating sleeping with anyone (0:52:21), and 'don't stick your dick in crazy' as the best dating advice (0:53:47).
Rubric version 1. Reviewed 18 November 2026.