WokeWarn
H Is for Hawk poster

Woke rating

H Is for Hawk

2025 · 120 min · Drama · Directed by Philippa Lowthorpe · IMDb

1.5/10

Mild

A quiet grief drama about a Cambridge historian who trains a goshawk after her father's death, with only a few passing progressive touches: an opening lecture on Rosalind Franklin, a quip about immigration and a line on biodiversity loss.

Philippa Lowthorpe's adaptation of Helen Macdonald's memoir stars Claire Foy as Helen, a Cambridge historian of science whose father (Brendan Gleeson), a press photographer, collapses and dies in a London street. Grieving, and about to lose her college post and house, she buys a young goshawk, names her Mabel and throws herself into training her, while her mother (Lindsay Duncan), her brother and her friends watch her withdraw. Flashbacks to her father and long, wordless stretches of falconry make up most of the film.

The messaging is confined to a few moments of Helen's working life. The opening scene is a lecture on how Rosalind Franklin's work was left out of the Watson and Crick story, framed as a challenge to the 'Great Man' view of science. At a college lunch she answers a guest who calls falconry good old Merrie England by saying Mabel is an immigrant, and her later seminar on extinction opens with a line about catastrophic biodiversity loss. Her short fling with Amar, an art dealer of Middle Eastern appearance, counts under the rubric's on-sight rule for interracial couples.

None of this recurs or steers the story, which is about grief. There are no villains and no politics beyond these lines, and the one argument the film stages, at Helen's seminar, is her defence of hunting against an audience member's animal-rights objection, which the rubric does not score. With so little messaging there is nothing for the film to mock or complicate, so no counterweight applies.

Score breakdown

Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.

CategoryScoreWhat we saw
Content
A Race and ethnicity 1

Race never comes up in the dialogue. Helen's only romance is a brief fling with Amar, a man of Middle Eastern appearance she met on Twitter, shown without comment and over within two scenes; scored 1 under the rubric's rule for a brief interracial couple.

  • 0:20:20Amar, an art dealer, joins Helen at a college dinner; they say they met on Twitter (0:20:34).
  • 0:21:28In bed together, Helen asks him to come to Berlin with her; a friend later tells her the relationship is not retrievable (0:22:38).
B Gender and feminism 1

One scene: the opening lecture uses Rosalind Franklin to argue that the history of science has been told as the story of great men. The theme does not return.

  • 0:04:51Helen asks her students what about Rosalind Franklin, without whose work Watson and Crick's breakthrough could not have happened.
  • 0:05:07She suggests scientific history has been dominated by the 'Great Man' theory and asks whether whoever tells the story wins the prize (0:05:20).
C Sexuality and gender identity 0

No LGBTQ+ content. Helen's only romance is with a man, and a friend's joke that the darkened hawk room looks like a fetish dungeon (0:41:56) is just a joke.

D Power and systems 0

Institutions appear only as a college that wants its classes taught and its pet rules kept (0:50:56, 0:59:48) and a policeman moving Helen's father on from a crime scene (0:16:53). Neither is framed as oppression of a group.

E Cultural and historical revision 0

An adaptation of Helen Macdonald's memoir about her own life. No established characters or history are recast; the Franklin point in the lecture is a familiar historical argument, not a revision.

F Religion portrayal 0

Islam is not portrayed. Religion appears only as the hymns and church setting of a memorial servicethe father's memorial service (1:09:56, 1:37:14).

Treatment
G Antagonist coding 0

There are no villains. The friction comes from grief, the hawk, Helen's worried family and her college superiors, none of them coded by group.

H Didacticism 1

Two of Helen's talks state a point directly, both in her own role as an academic: the Franklin lecture and the opening of her extinction seminar. Each is brief.

  • 0:04:59She tells her class that science is less objective than assumed and that societal factors deeply and invisibly shape it.
  • 1:25:34Her seminar opens by saying that in times of catastrophic biodiversity loss we must remember the world does not belong to us.
I Message over story 0

The story is driven by grief and the hawk, and none of the brief messages bends it.

J Left-leaning politics framed as good 1

Two brief touches lean left: a retort that punctures talk of falconry as old England, and a line on biodiversity loss. Neither recurs or is argued.

  • 1:02:26A guest calls falconry very Arthurian, good old Merrie England; Helen replies that Mabel is a Czech-German-Finnish immigrant (1:02:31).
  • 1:25:34The seminar's line on catastrophic biodiversity loss and sharing the world with other minds.

How the number is reached

  1. Categories A to J add up to 4 of 30, which gives 1.5 (4 ÷ 30 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
  2. No counterweight: The few messages are single lines or one scene and are neither argued against nor complicated; the film's only debate, at Helen's seminar, is about hunting rather than any of them.
  3. Final rating 1.5, mild.

Considered, scored 0

  • Helen turning down a merlin as 'a lady's bird' and insisting on a goshawk (0:26:28), a matter of character rather than a point about gender.
  • A passer-by from Almaty whose uncle is an eagle hunter (0:48:04), and the mixed students and fellows around the college, shown without comment.
  • Helen's grief and the toll it takes on her health and work, treated as personal, with no message attached.
  • Helen's father arguing with a policeman over photographing a crime scene (0:16:53), a family anecdote rather than a critique of the police.

Evidence and confidence

Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles (embedded track) and 114 frames sampled once a minute. Several stretches have no dialogue at all, mostly hawk training and flashback montage (for example 0:32:16 to 0:37:51, 1:03:22 to 1:06:17 and 1:13:33 to 1:16:37); these were checked in the frames only.

Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.

Noted, not scored: Helen defends hunting with a hawk against an audience member's charge of killing for fun, pointing to the millions of male chicks culled each year by the egg industry and calling hunting an honest encounter with death (1:25:45, 1:27:14).

Rubric version 1. Reviewed 18 November 2026.