WokeWarn
Clouds poster

Woke rating

Clouds

2020 · 121 min · Music, Drama · Directed by Justin Baldoni · IMDb

0.0/10

None or negligible

A true-story drama about a teenage songwriter with terminal cancer, with no progressive messaging: its themes are friendship, first love, family and making the most of limited time.

Justin Baldoni's film tells the story of Zach Sobiech (Fin Argus), a Minnesota high-school senior who learns that his bone cancer has spread and no longer responds to treatment. Given months to live, he writes songs with his best friend Sammy (Sabrina Carpenter), falls for his classmate Amy, and watches a homemade video turn into a songwriting deal.

There is nothing here for the rubric to score. The film's lessons are about using limited time well: a teacher asks the class what they will do with their 'one wild and precious life', Zach's mother tells him he can choose what matters, and Zach's own speeches are about fighting and living. The cast is mixed, but nobody remarks on race or sex, and the conflicts are with the illness, Zach's fear of becoming a sob story and the strain on his parents' marriage.

There is nothing here for the rubric to score. The film's lessons are about using limited time well: a teacher asks the class what they will do with their 'one wild and precious life', Zach's mother tells him he can choose what matters, and Zach's own speeches are about fighting and living. The cast is mixed, but nobody remarks on race or sex, and the conflicts are with the illness, Zach's fear of becoming a sob story, his break-up with Amy and the strain on his parents' marriage. The film ends with a concert in his honour, his death, and a card saying 'Clouds' reached number one on iTunes days later.

Where the film leans at all, it leans toward faith and family rather than politics: a pilgrimage to Lourdes, a funeral planned around a gospel reading, and a teenage romance imagined as marriage and six children. Those are noted below but not scored. With no political message anywhere, the score is zero.

Score breakdown

Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.

CategoryScoreWhat we saw
Content
A Race and ethnicity 0

Race is never a theme. Zach's mentor Mr. Weaver is Black (frame 0:20:30), and the school, hospital and concert crowds are mixed (frames 0:14:30, 1:41:30), all without comment. No interracial couple appears: Zach and Amy are both white (frame 0:51:30), as are his parents (frame 1:17:30).

B Gender and feminism 0

No gender message. Sammy is Zach's equal partner in the duo and is signed with him as a songwriter (1:15:08), presented as talent. A talent-show host ribs football players for dancing in skirts (0:01:16), and Laura's complaint that Rob has not looked at her in months (1:12:46) is grief straining a marriage, not a point about men.

C Sexuality and gender identity 0

No LGBTQ characters or themes. The romances are Zach and Amy and Sammy's unspoken crush on Zach (0:44:29).

D Power and systems 0

No institution is blamed. The doctors are frank and kind (0:14:13, 1:36:21), the music company and local radio champion Zach (1:15:08, 1:22:39), and his response to the disease is a research fund (1:21:59).

E Cultural and historical revision 0

Based on real events, as the closing card and the home videos of the real Zach and Sammy under the credits show (frames 1:53:30, 1:57:30). Nothing in the material presents any change as a point.

F Religion portrayal 0

Islam does not feature. The religion on screen is the family's Catholic faith.

Treatment
G Antagonist coding 0

There is no antagonist beyond the cancer. The only hostile voice is an anonymous YouTube commenter who says lots of kids have cancer (0:56:06).

H Didacticism 0

The speeches are about living fully, not about society: Mr. Weaver's Mary Oliver question (0:21:13), Laura's painting metaphor (0:25:40), Zach's concert speech (1:47:04) and his closing college essay (1:52:11).

I Message over story 0

A true-story illness and music drama whose turns follow the disease and the songs; nothing bends toward a message.

J Left-leaning politics framed as good 0

No political positions are argued or implied.

How the number is reached

  1. Categories A to J add up to 0 of 30, which gives 0.0 (0 ÷ 30 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
  2. No counterweight: There is no progressive messaging to mock or complicate.
  3. Final rating 0.0, none or negligible.

Considered, scored 0

  • Mr. Weaver, Zach's Black teacher and champion, who quotes Mary Oliver, Einstein and Sadie Delany (0:21:13, 1:15:32, 1:42:18); none of it touches race.
  • Mixed students, hospital staff and concert crowds (frames 0:14:30, 0:28:30, 1:41:30), shown without comment.
  • Sammy as an equal creative partner and co-signed songwriter (1:15:08), presented as talent rather than a point about women.
  • The host's joke about football players in skirts at the talent show (0:01:16), a ribbing between students and staff.

Evidence and confidence

Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles from the embedded track, including the song lyrics, and 121 frames sampled once a minute. The only gaps in the dialogue are wordless montages, the closing home videos and the end credits.

Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.

Noted, not scored: Faith is treated with respect: the family makes a pilgrimage to Lourdes (0:32:06), with Rob's scepticism given a fair voice (0:27:31); Zach chooses the parable of the talents for his funeral (1:31:51); and the film closes on a hopeful signa cloud shaped like a Z appears to his friends after his death (1:54:49). Traditional hopes for love and family: Amy imagines marriage and six children with Zach (0:52:01), and Laura is unhappy to find Amy has stayed the night, while Zach insists they only fell asleep (0:54:02).

Rubric version 1. Reviewed 18 November 2026.